Some things to think about

Overview

Teaching: 0 min
Exercises: 0 min

Questions

• Is there any room for improvement in the offline viewing experience?

• Why do some links still have targets that might be confusing?

Objectives

• Become aware of the way in which some links become “valid” when viewed via a webserver.

• Become aware of we might use the Software Carpentry build process to handle both online and offline viewing.

The previous episode left us with just three links, on each of the pages, episodes and auxilliary content, that would, when served by a webserver, point, correctly, to remote resources but which when viewed offline, have targets that may appear broken.

This episode will merely discuss ways in which the Lesson styles’ templates might be altered, so as to address those issues.

How many navigational links remain broken, when viewed offline ?

Same question as before, but now we are down to just three links

Main title bar

* Improve this page
    * RemoteRepoURI/edit/path

LHS Footer Menu

* Edit on GitHub
    * RemoteRepoURI/edit/path

* Source
    * RemoteRepoURI/

although two of those are duplicates, albeit under different names within the page, to the same target.

It is instructive to look at what targets these links have under different viewing regimes and in this instance we will consider the “Home Page” of the Lesson, index.html.

Viewed as the GitHub repo’s gh-pages branch at github.io

https://github.com/vuw-ecs-kevin/offline-capable-lesson/edit/gh-pages/index.md

https://github.com/vuw-ecs-kevin/offline-capable-lesson/

Following a make serve

http://127.0.0.1:4000/edit/gh-pages/index.md

http://127.0.0.1:4000/

Following a make site

file:///edit/gh-pages/index.md

file:///

It should be pretty clear what is going on here but, to make things obvious, we’ll break it down

https://github.com/vuw-ecs-kevin/offline-capable-lesson/ + edit/gh-pages/index.md

https://github.com/vuw-ecs-kevin/offline-capable-lesson/


http://127.0.0.1:4000/                                   + edit/gh-pages/index.md

http://127.0.0.1:4000/


file:///                                                 + edit/gh-pages/index.md

file:///

Basicaly then, the targets of these links are only valid when the lesson content has been rendered within an environment where the path to the Lesson’s GitHub repo can be determined.

The targets for these links would typically be determined by using the jekyll-github-metatdata gem, as described here

https://github.com/jekyll/github-metadata

however that can require one to have access to the GitHub repo at the time that one creates the rendered Lesson.

An alternative approach would be to check for the existence of the variables that jekyll-github-metatdata would populate and, if they don’t exist, the use a local variable, that can be added into the Lesson’s _config.yml to provide the desired link target.

Note that, just as with the definition of the variable to hold index.html, so as to allow for offline navigation within a Lessons, if a Lesson’s authors decide not to populate a variable to hold the URL of the repository, then the rendered content will remain the same.

If we have defined a variable static_repo_url then we just need to edit two files in the current Lesson styles template

• _includes/lesson_footer.html
• _includes/navbar.html

so that references to site.github.repository_url get wrapped in an if-then-else clause similar to this one, from _includes/lesson_footer.html

    {% if site.github.repository_url %}
    <a href="{{ site.github.repository_url }}/">Source</a>
    {% else %}
    <a href="{{ site.static_repo_url }}/">Source</a>
    {% endif %}

Note that this modification also fixes up the targets of the external links when the lesson is viewed using Jekyll’s own webserver, during a make serve.

Key Points

• Some links in the offline rendered Lesson still have confusing targets when the lesson is viewed offline, or in Jekyll’s own server .

• Software Capentry’s build process allows for alterations in the content that gets rendered, based on global/lesson variables.

• It may be possible to render an offilne resource so that all the links have valid targets.